BILT Speaker

BILT Speaker
RevitCat - Revit Consultant

Saturday, 13 April 2019

Revit Conceptual Massing Environment - Index


Over the years I have struggled with the Conceptual Massing Environment (CME) in Revit.  It is not easy to use, and is not at all well integrated with the rest of Revit.  However, I have learnt a huge amount about how to get it to do what you want (or not!).  I have tried to document some of the tips and tricks on this blog and during various conference presentations that I have given at RTC & BILT .

Here is a summary / index of all the relevant posts on this blog:

Conceptual Massing Environment

Rival Revit Environments - Traditional vs Conceptual Massing Environment (CME)







 

Creating Traditional Forms using Conceptual Massing

Part 1 - Extrusion 
             Extrusion Offset Properties
Part 2 - Blend
Part 3 - Revolve
Part 4 - Sweep
Part 5 - Swept Blend
Part 6 - Loft
 
Part 7 - Hybrid Swept Blend / Loft


Revit Nurby Forms at BILTANZ

Adaptive Components

Adaptive Components

Adaptive components are a subset of the Conceptual Massing Environment:

Repeaters

Repeaters are a kind of array, in the CME world . . .

Modelling Santiago Calatrava's Gare do Oriente (Lisbon) using Repeaters:
Step 5  Assembling the Array of Structural Columns



Revit Ideas - Vote to Improve the Conceptual Massing Environment in Revit:


Some of the problems could be alleviated by the following capabilities - please vote for them on the Autodesk Revit Ideas wish-list if you agree:



Monday, 1 April 2019

Stepped Steps in Revit Stairs


I had a question recently about how to create a Revit stair that is stepped in plan?  It is actually not that hard to do but the method is not so intuitive - so here are some instructions:

Tapered Stair

For the record, we'll start with a tapered stair, to get the methodology - as that is very easy:
  • Create a stair with a straight run
 
  • Select the run (in stair edit mode)
  •  Convert the run to a sketch 
 
  • Select the run and 'Edit Sketch'
 
  • Adjust the angle of one or both sides
 
  • No need to trim the riser lines (providing the boundary lines up with the end risers
  • Finish the sketch and the stair



Stepped Stair

Follow a similar process as the tapered stair to start with:

  • Create a stair with a straight run
 
  • Select the run (in stair edit mode)
  • Convert the run to a sketch - this stage is not reversible, so you need to be sure about it
 
  • Select the run and 'Edit Sketch'
  • The sides and back of each step need to be drawn as 'Boundary Lines', which show green in the sketch mode [Refer to Poor Man's Array for a tip on how to do this]
  • As per the tapered stair, the riser lines do not need to extend out to the boundary lines - this makes it easier to sketch and to modify later
 
  • Finish the sketch and the stair


You may get some interesting results with the railings, but that can be dealt with in the next blog post . . . . Stepped Handrails in Revit



Sunday, 17 March 2019

Glazed Doors in Window and Door Schedules in Revit

I started out writing this blog post about the behaviour of subcategories in nested families.  On closer investigation, the weird behaviour I intended documenting was not as I had thought - still a bit strange but not quite worthy of a post all to itself.  So I have changed tack and turned it into a discussion about how to get a glazed door family to appear in both door and window schedules.  Many experienced Revit users should already know this, but for those who do not, read on.

Schedules and Categories

Typically door and window schedules are created separately as single category schedules. Multi-category schedules have too many limitations to make them work efficiently for this task. A door or a window is usually either one of those categories, and therefore it can only appear in one of the schedules.  What if you have a window assembly that contains a glazed door? or a sliding glass door, which you want to show in the window schedule (because it is glazing), but also in the door schedule (because it hosts door hardware)?  This common requirement seems problematic in Revit, but there is a way around it . . .

Workaround:

Shared Nested Family

When a nested family is 'Shared', it behaves differently to the parent family in terms of subcategories.
For example, you might have a window parent family, that contains just a frame (or a fixed glass side panel).  Inside this could be a nested sliding door family.  Providing the door family is set to 'Shared', then it can have its subcategories independently controlled (by View Visibility) in the project;  it can also be individually selected, tagged and scheduled (as a door); the parent family can be tagged and scheduled as a window.

Nested Door Family Category Settings

Nested Door Family Subcategory

Parent Window Family

Parent Family Category

Parent Family Subcategories

Nested Door Family in Parent Family

Tagging and Schedules

Standard door and window families are normally tagged separately according to category
Once placed in a project, the combined door/window family can be tagged for either category:




Tag the whole family for the window category tag

Tab select the nested door family to tag it

Scheduling

  • The combined window/door family will appear in a window schedule. 
  • The Nested door family will appear in a door schedule

Category Visibility

This example shows a single swing door nested family in a window family (with fixed window panels either side).  In the project, both door and window categories/subcategories affect the sub-element display:
All Categories On

Door Panel Subcategory Off

Window Category Off - Door Category On

Non-shared Nested Family Categories

When a normal 'non-shared' family of one category is nested inside another family of a different category, it behaves as if it is part of the parent family in terms of categories.
Unshared Family Settings
In the parent family (in Family Editor), the nested family still shows its category when selected
Non-Shared Nested Door Family in Window Parent Family
When loaded into a project the whole window can be selected, but not the nested door family. 

Window family with non-shared nested door - in project

Changing the visibility of the Door category does not affect the nested door.
Door Category Off, Window Category Visible

Hiding the Window category, (while the door category is visible) hides the whole family, including the nested door
Door Category Visible, Window Category Off

This behaviour is as expected.

Weird Revit Behaviour:

Non-Shared Nested Families

However, if the nested families have elements of a specific subcategory (of the Nested family category - door) the element's visibility is still controlled by that nested family subcategory.  This does not really make sense if the nested family is not shared.
Door Panel Subcategory Off


This can be very confusing, as you have no way of knowing what category the nested family is, without editing the parent family.  As far as the user is concerned, the family is a window - since you cannot select the nested door in the project, the user will not be aware that it even has a nested family, let alone that a subcategory that has nothing to do with windows will still affect it.


Sunday, 17 February 2019

Stretcher Bond Hatching in Revit

A few years back I posted a description of how to create a complex custom hatch pattern for Revit - that example was for repeating octagons.  Since then I have often needed to quickly create much simpler patterns such as stretcher bond elevation views for bricks, blocks and tiles.  The Octagon pattern was quite complex and it still takes a while to get your head around the logic - so here is a much easier to follow set of examples:


Pattern Definition Format

The pattern file is a text file, saved with a '.pat' extension.
Definition of units (important for metric):
;%UNITS=MM

Each pattern definition has an * prefixed header :   a title and description separated by a comma
      *Stretcher 400x200,   400mm x 200mm stretcher bond
Drafting or Model definition:
       ;%TYPE=MODEL
Each line repeat (in the pattern) is described in one row of text, with comma delimited format.  eg:
0,     1200, 1000,         0,  1000,       400,  -1500

  • Angle  = angle of line from horizontal measured in an anti-clockwise direction
  • Origin x = horizontal distance of start of line from setout point (always orthogonal)
  • Origin y = vertical distance of start of line from setout point (always orthogonal)
  • Shift u (x axis of line) = offset distance of start of repeat line measured parallel to start of line
    (in the direction of the line,  ie. to match the angle).  The Shift values are measured from the start of the line, not from the setout point.
  • Shift v (y axis of line) = offset distance of start of repeat line measured perpendicular to start of line
  • Pen down = length of solid line measured in the direction of the line (optional - it draws a continuous line if omitted)
  • Pen up = length of gap in the line before the next segment of the line starts repeating (measured in the direction of the line);  is always a minus value.  (optional - as per pen down)
NB. I have labelled the shift directions as u & v (not x & y, as Autodesk labels them) because the directions relate to the axis of the line, not the whole pattern - so a vertical line would have a u offset measured vertically (labelled as x direction by Autodesk, which is confusing).

Stretcher Bond Hatching Definitions


A typical staggered tile pattern (stretcher bond) consists of :
  • a series of continuous horizontal lines at regular spacing;
  • Short vertical lines that run between alternate horizontal lines, at a spacing equal to the length of the brick/block/tile
  • Another set of short vertical lines that run between alternate horizontal lines, at a spacing equal to the length of the brick/block/tile - but these are typically offset horizontally by half a length and vertically by one pattern height.
These should almost always be defined as MODEL patterns, as they are meant to be dimensionally correct on the surface of the material.

There are actually two ways to define this:

Option 1 - separate definitions for the two vertical lines

*Stretcher-450x150-1/2,      450 x 150 1/2 stretcher bond
;%TYPE=MODEL
0,         0,0,           0,150
90,       0,0,           0,450,        150,-150
90,    225,150,      0,450,        150,-150

The first row defines the horizontal lines
0,         0,0,           0,150
  • The lines are at zero degrees (horizontal)
  • The first line starts at 0 offset from the origin, both x and y (0,0)
  •  The repeat has a shift of zero horizontally (x or u), and 150mm vertically (y or v) from the line origin (0,150),
  • The next repeat is the same values (0,150) from the start of the previous repeat. 
  • The line is continuous, as the are no pen up/down values




The second row defines the first set of vertical lines
90,       0,0,           0,450,        150,-150
  • The lines are at 90 degrees (vertical )
  • The first line starts at 0 offset from the origin, both x and y (0,0)
  •  The repeat has a shift of zero vertically (u) , and 450mm horizontally (v) , from the line origin (0,450)
  • The next repeat is the same values (0,450) from the start of the previous repeat. 
  • The line is segmented, 150mm solid, 150mm gap (pen up/down 150,-150)
The v shift in this instance is horizontal, perpendicular to the line, with a positive value to the left of the line origin (same as pattern setout point in this case). 
  • As the pattern is symmetrical, it makes no difference if the v shift value is positive or negative
  • Seen below in context, the pattern repeats in both directions from the origin:








The third row defines the second set of vertical lines
90,    225,150,      0,450,        150,-150
  • The lines are at 90 degrees (vertical )
  • The first line starts at 225mm x offset from the origin, and 150mm y offset from the origin (225,150) - ie. half a tile along and one tile up.
  • The repeat has a shift of zero vertically (u) , and 450mm horizontally (v) , from the line origin (0,450)
  • The next repeat is the same values (0,450) from the start of the previous repeat. 
  • The line is segmented, 150mm solid, 150mm gap (pen up/down 150,-150)
 


Option 2 - one definition for both vertical lines

*Stretcher-450x150-1/2,      450 x 150 1/2 stretcher bond
;%TYPE=MODEL
0,         0,0,           0,150
90,       0,0,       150,225,        150,-150


The first row defines the horizontal lines as per previous method
0,         0,0,           0,150

The second row defines the vertical lines
90,       0,0,       150,225,        150,-150
  • The lines are at 90 degrees (vertical )
  • The first line starts at 0 offset from the origin, both x and y (0,0)
  •  The repeat has a shift of 150mm vertically (u) , and 225mm horizontally (v) , from the line origin (150,225)
  • The next repeat is the same values (150,225) from the start of the previous repeat. 
  • The line is segmented, 150mm solid, 150mm gap (pen up/down 150,-150)


  • As the pattern is symmetrical, it makes no difference if the u and v shift values are positive or negative
  • Seen below in context, the pattern repeats in both directions from the origin:


One Third Shift Patterns

The same principles can be applied when the bond is staggered by differing proportions.


Option 1 - separate definitions for each vertical line


*Stretcher-450x150-1/3,   450 x 150 1/3 stretcher bond
;%TYPE=MODEL
0,          0,0,         0,150
90,        0,0,         0,450,       150,-300 
90,    150,150,     0,450,       150,-300
90,    300,300,     0,450,       150,-300


 90,    150,150,     0,450,       150,-300

  • 90 degrees
  • 150mm x line origin, 150mm y line origin
  • Zero u shift repeat, 450mm v shift repeat
  • 150mm Pen Down, 300mm gap (Pen Up)




 90,    300,300,     0,450,       150,-300
  • 90 degrees
  • 300mm x line origin, 300mm y line origin
  • Zero u shift repeat, 450mm v shift repeat
  • 150mm Pen Down, 300mm gap (Pen Up)

Option 2 - one definitions for all vertical lines

*Stretcher-450x150-1/2,      450 x 150 1/2 stretcher bond
;%TYPE=MODEL
0,         0,0,           0,150
90,       0,0,       150,300,        150,-300
Horizontal shift (v) repeat has to be 2/3 of a tile (300mm)

As the joint offset is not half a tile, the same result can be achieved with a negative v shift repeat of -150mm:
0,         0,0,           0,150
90,       0,0,       150,-150,        150,-300



An offset by one third to the left could be achieved by a positive 150mm v shift:
0,         0,0,           0,150
90,       0,0,       150,150,        150,-300


Two Third Shift Patterns

Some patterns cannot have their vertical lines defined by only one row, as you can't define a consistent diagonal repeat.  Therefore you must have multiple rows for the vertical lines.

*Staggered-450x150-2/3, 450 x 150 2/3 stretcher bond
;%TYPE=MODEL
0,          0,0,        0,150
90,        0,0,        0,450,     150,-150
90,    300,150,    0,450,     150,-150








The direction of stagger can be changed with the x origin value:

*Staggered-450x150+2/3, 450 x 150 2/3 stretcher bond
;%TYPE=MODEL
0,          0,0,        0,150
90,        0,0,        0,450,     150,-150
90,    150,150,    0,450,     150,-150

Flemish Bond

More complex brick patterns require extra rows of definition:


*Flemish-240x86,     240 x 86 (Australian Brick size) Flemish stretcher bond
;%TYPE=MODEL
0,           0,0,         0,86
90,         0,0,         0,360,       86,-86 
90,      240,0,        0,360,       86,-86
90,        60,86,      0,360,       86,-86
90,      180,86,      0,360,       86,-86




You could continue this theme with increasing random looking patterns, but I'll leave that for you to figure out . . . . . .